Emeterio's Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Fulton, NY, Emeterio's Pizzeria serves up an authentic Italian pizza experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. Specializing in brick-oven pizza with a distinctive New York flair, Emeterio's presents a menu packed with classic favorites and hearty options that delight the senses from the very first bite.

The star of the show has to be their sheet pizza, praised by patrons for its genuine Italian roots and vibrant flavor profile. Made with what customers describe as “straight up Italian pizza made with love,” the crust strikes the perfect balance — crisp on the outside and tender within, far removed from the typical premade dough found elsewhere. Rich, tangy sauce, rumored to be crafted from San Marzano tomatoes, enhances each slice with its deep, sun-ripened essence. For those craving a classic treat, the NY Style pizza offers a sizeable and satisfying pie that'll transport you straight to the streets of New York.

Beyond pizza, Emeterio’s offers an enticing selection of calzones and stromboli, with creamy ricotta and mozzarella folding into each calzone, and the stromboli packed generously with sauce and mozzarella cheese — each priced reasonably to reflect the quality and portion size. Their hot heroes lineup is another crowd-pleaser: from the savory Chicken Philly stacked with tender chicken and American cheese, to the spicy kick of Buffalo Chicken, and the comforting layers of the Meatball Parmigiana sub. Each sandwich is crafted with fresh ingredients and toasted to perfection, offering a hearty alternative to pizza without sacrificing flavor.

The atmosphere at Emeterio's is casual and inviting—perfect for a quick pick-up or a relaxed meal at home, as dine-in options are limited. Customers appreciate the genuine friendliness and attentive service that matches the excellence of the food. Though prices lean slightly high, fans agree the quality and taste make it worth every penny.

While their food preparation is speedy, ensuring you’re not left waiting, some details like the sheet pizza’s cutting have drawn minor critique, suggesting a bit more attention to finish could elevate the experience further. Nevertheless, the overall consensus remains overwhelmingly positive, with many lauding the consistently delicious flavors and authentic touch that makes Emeterio’s stand out in the Fulton dining scene.

For anyone eager to indulge in expertly crafted brick-oven pizza paired with classic Italian-American favorites, Emeterio's Pizzeria is a must-visit. Whether dining in on a day off or picking up for a casual night in, this spot promises bold flavors and heartfelt cooking that truly embody the spirit of traditional pizzeria fare.